compostgoblin@slrpnk.net to Memes@lemmy.mlEnglish · 10 months agoBut "socialism" is a scary wordslrpnk.netexternal-linkmessage-square74fedilinkarrow-up144arrow-down11
arrow-up143arrow-down1external-linkBut "socialism" is a scary wordslrpnk.netcompostgoblin@slrpnk.net to Memes@lemmy.mlEnglish · 10 months agomessage-square74fedilink
minus-squareNSRXN@lemmy.dbzer0.comlinkfedilinkarrow-up0arrow-down1·10 months ago those can’t exist in actual human communities of more than about a dozen people. this is a lie.
minus-squaremerc@sh.itjust.workslinkfedilinkarrow-up0·10 months agoOk, then disprove it. Show a counterexample.
minus-squareNSRXN@lemmy.dbzer0.comlinkfedilinkarrow-up0arrow-down1·10 months agoinvaded by imperial france
minus-squaremerc@sh.itjust.workslinkfedilinkarrow-up0·10 months agoAfter a whole 2 months. Clearly if one of your prime examples is something that couldn’t even last a quarter of a year, you don’t have a leg to stand on.
minus-squareNSRXN@lemmy.dbzer0.comlinkfedilinkarrow-up0arrow-down1·10 months agobeing invaded by a superpower is not an indictment of a societal structure
minus-squaremerc@sh.itjust.workslinkfedilinkarrow-up0·10 months agoNot being able to defend itself is indeed an indictment of a societal structure.
minus-squareNSRXN@lemmy.dbzer0.comlinkfedilinkarrow-up0arrow-down1·10 months agowhat city could have survived an attack from France? none. you will never find any true Scotsman.
minus-squareNSRXN@lemmy.dbzer0.comlinkfedilinkarrow-up0arrow-down1·10 months agoseems like you’re no true scotsmanning. say what you want to say
minus-squareNSRXN@lemmy.dbzer0.comlinkfedilinkarrow-up0arrow-down1·10 months agoit’s an anarchist community of 55,000
minus-squareNSRXN@lemmy.dbzer0.comlinkfedilinkarrow-up0arrow-down1·10 months agomore no true scotsmanning
minus-squareNSRXN@lemmy.dbzer0.comlinkfedilinkarrow-up0arrow-down1·10 months agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_stateless_societies?wprov=sfla1
this is a lie.
Ok, then disprove it. Show a counterexample.
the Paris commune
How did that end?
invaded by imperial france
After a whole 2 months. Clearly if one of your prime examples is something that couldn’t even last a quarter of a year, you don’t have a leg to stand on.
being invaded by a superpower is not an indictment of a societal structure
Not being able to defend itself is indeed an indictment of a societal structure.
what city could have survived an attack from France? none. you will never find any true Scotsman.
the swamp maroons
How did that end?
seems like you’re no true scotsmanning.
say what you want to say
exarcheia
What about it?
it’s an anarchist community of 55,000
And it’s not in a country?
more no true scotsmanning
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_stateless_societies?wprov=sfla1